Single Family Home for Sale in Edgartown, #41159

Single Family Homes - Edgartown Downtown | 43 Peases Point Way South Edgartown MA
  • Rooms/BD
  • Bath(s)
  • SqF
    5,458 ft²
  • Price

43 Peases Point Way South is where warmth and style meet sophistication, creating a truly one-of-a-kind living experience in the heart of Edgartown Village. Once you step through the gated arbor, you are welcomed by a lovely courtyard, creating the first of many unexpected and special moments carefully planned to provide the utmost privacy and tranquility, whether indoors or out. The Patrick Ahearn-designed home, just a short stroll away from Main Street shops, restaurants and the scenic Edgartown harbor, is elevated by its exceptional interior finishes and distinctive floor plan. Unparalleled luxury is carried through all levels of living, including an awe-inspiring outdoor space anchored by a remarkable salt water pool with a sunken fire pit and unique custom glass wall feature. Perfectly curated and luxurious furnishings only further enhance each space, making a turn-key opportunity possible. Completed in 2023, this phenomenal property has set a new elite standard.

Floor 1: Upon entry through the charming Dutch door, your view is carried across the light-filled living room that dramatically opens to the backyard. Access is effortless, as full glass accordion style French doors lead to the inground pool complete with a recessed fire pit, baja lounging shelves, spa and built-in bbq, all of which are perfectly framed by the detached cabana complete with wet bar, fireplace, bathroom and easy access to the outdoor shower. An impressive chef's kitchen is centered around a large quartz island, beautifully customized with a white oak inlay detail that complements the variable sized white oak floors throughout the home, underscoring the attention to detail evident across this property. The open concept main living space also offers a separate dining area, creating the perfect gathering space. The primary suite is the ultimate sanctuary, complemented by a cathedral ceiling, luxurious bath and large walk-in closet. A gallery hallway, framed by a beautiful mahogany barreled ceiling, leads to the mud room with laundry and nautical themed half bath. Further down the hall, you’ll find a generous sized guestroom that shares a full bath with the front parlor, the most historic part of the home, ideal for a quiet workspace or overflow.

Floor 2: A large guest room with a private bath awaits at the top of the elegant staircase accented by beautiful pendant lighting.

Basement: An open staircase off of the front foyer descends seamlessly into the lower level, leading to completely unexpected and sprawling additional recreational and living spaces in the home. Accented by 10’ ceilings and flooded with natural light, the level boasts another large family room with large screen TV, a club game room area, fully equipped bar and a separate wine room. Also featured is a stunning multi-tiered theater room, cleverly customized and complete with a candy bar - the perfect spot to enjoy the latest blockbuster or pivotal sporting event. Further down the vaulted hallway is a private dry sauna and steam room, a luxury rarely found, alongside a fully equipped gym. The final destination, at the very end of the hall, is a remarkably bright and spacious bedroom with ensuite full bath. The ultimate private retreat.

Other Buildings: Detached single car garage, with plenty of room for storage of bikes and all other summertime gear.

Second Dwelling:


Indoor amenities
Gym / Fitness Center
Outdoor amenities
Hot Tub
Swimming Pool

©2023 LINK, All Rights Reserved. Not responsible for misinformation or typographical errors. Prices are subject to change without notice. Listed by: Sandpiper Realty


  • Listing ID: 41159
  • Year Built: 1840
  • Flooring: White Oak
  • Yard: Professionally landscaped
  • Foundation: Full
  • Water: Town
  • Heating: Heat Pump